Originally Posted by
dogfish
The Raiders hired an experienced former HC with a decade's experience as a coordinator, how's that working out?
Why, because our Super Bowl window is open right now? Look at Quinn's Atlanta tenure-- their only real success came because of Kyle Shanahan, DQ's other two OC hires were freakin' Steve Sarkisian and Dirk Koetter. Last year, during the hiring process, Woody even floated a trial balloon naming Quinn's potential staff. I can't remember who the name was for OC, but it was another stodgy old retread. Think Mike Mularkey, Doug Marrone, Bill O'Brien. You guys think one of those dopes can get the most out of Russ? I don't. May as well bring back Shurmur, he's got lots of experience.
Seriously, what kind of person lets past mistakes define them for the rest of their life? We failed with VJ and Hackett because they're morons, not because they were first time HCs. I will never understand how Donkeys fans can look at what's happening in Philly, Minnesota, Miami, NYG, and not want some of that. It's like "I asked out the pretty girl and she said no-- guess I better go for an ugly one next time." Denver has failed with Tommy Maddox, Tim Tebow, Paxton Lynch and Drew Lock. Does that mean they should never spend a high draft pick on a QB again, and should be relegated to journeyman scrubs and over the hill vets for all eternity? No. You get up, dust yourself off, and do better next time. How many QB busts have the Bengals drafted? Doesn't matter, they dancin' now. Evero is freakin' smart. My level of confidence that he could figure out clock management is very high. It isn't gawd damn rocket surgery.
Look at the teams favored to make the Super Bowl. Andy Reid is the only retread HC in the group. If we can get Payton, who's the closest thing to an Andy equivalent, then I'm all in. And I'd take Frank Reich in a heartbeat. If it's not one of those two (or maybe Harbaugh), then count me out on experienced guys who are proven to be thoroughly mediocre. I'd rather fail spectacularly yet again with a bright young guy than hire some John Fox or Jeff Fisher type just because they're the safe move. JMO.