Thread: Who is the best WR all time? In their prime.

Originally Posted by King87

It just feels like when you go 'who was the best at their best' Megatron starts laughing at every other WR and progressively gets more disrespectful with his laugh.

Interesting take.

Originally Posted by Canmore

Interesting take.

Your kind words warm my heart in these trying times of sadness.

Originally Posted by Nomad

Who can forget Moss’s awareness on this play? He was also intelligent as much as physically talented.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=p8o--gh5R98

Lol I didn’t even have to click the video to know what you was talking about. Soon as I seen moss I knew what time it was lol. Definitely one of the most heart breaking plays in my history as a broncos fan.

This is a question that can never be answered. It’s all opinion based. There are just way too many dominant WRs with different play styles to name the best one ever.

Smh I don’t know why you folks are even trying to debate this

Originally Posted by Mozzafiato

Yup. Rice had that cold blooded killer in him more than guys like Johnson and Moss did.

Lol rice had that cold blooded killer in his more than moss and Johnson? Come on mannnnnnn this don’t even make sense bro. How do you measure cold blooded killer?? Moss in between them lines was an assassin that knew he was better than ANYBODY on defense every week and treated them as such. There’s nothing more cold blooded than taking off and within team years just throwing up his hand to say yeah these guys are already toast and then going to
Get the ball to the point a term was created in every inner city and probably everywhere else
Suburbs and all where we was playing football and saying you got MOSSED. Then it reached college and everywhere else getting mossed lol

Originally Posted by OrangeHoof

Anyone who doesn't think Jerry Rice is the best does not deserve to post on a football forum. I'm sorry. It's the height of ignorance to suggest anyone else.

Lol this is trolling at its finest. Ain’t noway you believe this shit

Oh, but I do. The numbers back it up - and I'm not a 49ers fan or a Jerry Rice fan.

https://www.pro-football-reference.c...rec_career.htm

https://www.pro-football-reference.c...yds_career.htm

https://www.pro-football-reference.c..._td_career.htm

Most catches. Most yards. Most TDs.

Any other questions?

Originally Posted by OrangeHoof

Oh, but I do. The numbers back it up - and I'm not a 49ers fan or a Jerry Rice fan.

https://www.pro-football-reference.c...rec_career.htm

https://www.pro-football-reference.c...yds_career.htm

https://www.pro-football-reference.c..._td_career.htm

Most catches. Most yards. Most TDs.

Any other questions?

No doubt rice best all time. His a career might never be matched. But to debate an “in their prime” only is interesting, there is a list of “In their prime “ players that could arguable have been as or maybe even more dominant for a short window.

There are other factors such as time/era played in but im still of the belief that Rice would be just as good now as he was then. Same thing with the Michael Jordan debate.

It's either Rice or Moss. I view this much like the Manning Brady debate. I think Manning was a more skilled football player, but Brady's career was greater.

In this case, I think Moss is the most talented WR of all time but Rice is the greatest, if that makes sense.

Originally Posted by Eddiemac87

No doubt rice best all time. His a career might never be matched. But to debate an “in their prime” only is interesting, there is a list of “In their prime “ players that could arguable have been as or maybe even more dominant for a short window.

No doubt there were days a receiver bested Rice in the first half. "In their prime" is a b.s. argument for people who can always move the goalposts to support their claim.

Originally Posted by OrangeHoof

No doubt there were days a receiver bested Rice in the first half. "In their prime" is a b.s. argument for people who can always move the goalposts to support their claim.

"In their prime" is literally the topic of the thread, no one is moving any goalposts. Also, no one is talking about one half of a game, so I'm not sure what you're on about here. A "prime" is usually considered a player's best couple of seasons or so.