Thread: Public Service Announcement- The GOAT!!!

Nevermind Joe won’t accept it.

Originally Posted by Jeudy10Hamler1

Gordon was good today but the real story was Williams just killing shit. Loved how they both had almost 200 yards rushing with Williams at 111 and Gordon at 80.

The Philip Lindsay crowd has been beaten into submission so I’m going to hold back from any chest pounding

Too bad your word is empty of meaning!

Originally Posted by Jeudy10Hamler1

Nevermind Joe won’t accept it.

Lindsay was an amazing story. Two 1,000 yard seasons out of the gate, zero fumbles.

He's no YD, but dude had talent until this coaching staff showed up.

How can you blame them for Lock, but not Phil?

Originally Posted by BroncoJoe

Lindsay was an amazing story. Two 1,000 yard seasons out of the gate, zero fumbles.

He's no YD, but dude had talent until this coaching staff showed up.

How can you blame them for Lock, but not Phil?

*TD

He's been good each season he's played in with one large exception. And that exception happens to be the season he's on...the worst team/organization in the NFL.

I don't deny that he was overrated a little bit. But it is hard for me to think he was that overrated to the point whereby this dropoff is mostly on him.

Originally Posted by BroncoJoe

How can you blame them for Lock, but not Phil?

How do you explain the success of Williams and MGIII with the same coaching staff though?

Originally Posted by Northman

How do you explain the success of Williams and MGIII with the same coaching staff though?

I think all three are good RB's.

I think Houston is where talent goes to die...or behave poorly at massage parlors.

Originally Posted by King87

I think all three are good RB's.

I think Houston is where talent goes to die...or behave poorly at massage parlors.

Im not so sure, Texans are struggling but its because they have zero good backs there. All of them, and i mean ALL of them are 2nd and 3rd string RB material.

Originally Posted by BroncoJoe

*TD

TD gave a pep talk to the running backs before the game. I saw it on a video at Denver Broncos or Denver Broncos CBS. It worked.

Originally Posted by Northman

Im not so sure, Texans are struggling but its because they have zero good backs there. All of them, and i mean ALL of them are 2nd and 3rd string RB material.

I'd believe that but Lindsay did well in Denver. Houston is bad. The Texans have backs other than Lindsay that haven't been great in awhile. I guess Lindsay's earned the benefit of the doubt in my eyes.

Originally Posted by King87

I'd believe that but Lindsay did well in Denver. Houston is bad. The Texans have backs other than Lindsay that haven't been great in awhile. I guess Lindsay's earned the benefit of the doubt in my eyes.

I think Lindsay's success in Denver is more of a aberration rather than a statement about how good he was/is. I akin Lindsay to Olandis Gary or Michael Anderson where they had some good seasons but once they moved on they did almost nothing for other franchises. But then when you see a guy like Portis who had success on multiple franchises it sets itself apart in my opinion. Lindsay having a couple of successful seasons is much like Derek Anderson having one good year as a QB in Cleveland in my opinion. MGIII has been good for both the Chargers and now Denver.

I’m not tech savvy enough to post the video , so I took a screen shot.

Originally Posted by Northman

I think Lindsay's success in Denver is more of a aberration rather than a statement about how good he was/is. I akin Lindsay to Olandis Gary or Michael Anderson where they had some good seasons but once they moved on they did almost nothing for other franchises. But then when you see a guy like Portis who had success on multiple franchises it sets itself apart in my opinion. Lindsay having a couple of successful seasons is much like Derek Anderson having one good year as a QB in Cleveland in my opinion. MGIII has been good for both the Chargers and now Denver.

That's interesting. I guess I give him the benefit of the doubt because he did well on some pretty poorly QB'd teams. With that being said, I can't tell you that you're wrong. My knock on him was his rookie year he broke a bone in his arm, and he got nicked up in his second year. Durability was an issue, no matter what anyone said. For all I 'know' he was a good back but is physically spent now. For all I know, he was a system player. Or somewhere in between.

Originally Posted by BroncoJoe

Lindsay was an amazing story. Two 1,000 yard seasons out of the gate, zero fumbles.

He's no YD, but dude had talent until this coaching staff showed up.

How can you blame them for Lock, but not Phil?

Because Phil went elsewhere and totally failed……. And also none of the other backs here are failing in the run game it was only Lindsay….!.

It's a worthless debate, and I'll bow out by saying Lindsay isn't a run up the gut RB, but that's what Shurmer asked him to do.

You can't just dismiss his two year production.