Thread: Gardner Minshew

Originally Posted by Canmore

Wave has spoken... so much like J10H1

My statement can be backed up with data.

Originally Posted by QBronco

Quarterback skills= 5

Facial Hair skills= Solid 10

Way to high on skills. To low on stache.

Originally Posted by BroncoWave

My statement can be backed up with data.

Congrats...

Originally Posted by Hawgdriver

Yeah, I get the impression Atwater was 100% serious. Or that's some ballin deadpan. You think he means that Minshew should be the starter?

Absolutely, he and Wave really like his stat line.

Originally Posted by Jaded

Absolutely, he and Wave really like his stat line.

he must have some good stats then.

I figure it's good luck.

But you think it's good luck too? Or do you think he's just not physically talented enough?

Originally Posted by Hawgdriver

he must have some good stats then.

I figure it's good luck.

But you think it's good luck too? Or do you think he's just not physically talented enough?

He’s a scrub, objectively he’s a marginal practice squad talent. I have yet to put enough effort into understanding what you people see in scrubs so don’t ask me to explain it.

Originally Posted by Jaded

He’s a scrub, objectively he’s a marginal practice squad talent. I have yet to put enough effort into understanding what you people see in scrubs so don’t ask me to explain it.

Lock fans: It's irrelevant that minshew has such better stats than Lock, he's trash!

Also Lock fans: Would you look at Lock's training camp stats compared to TB!!!!

“Imagine thinking stats are relevant whatsoever“—BridgewaterWave

Originally Posted by Jaded

“Imagine thinking stats are relevant whatsoever“—BridgewaterWave

Stats in real games against other teams are very much relevant. Stats in scripted training camp drills against your own defense, most of which hasn't even been in full pads, are not.

Originally Posted by Jaded

“Imagine thinking stats are relevant whatsoever“—BridgewaterWave

Are you 12? I’m being serious.

Originally Posted by atwater27

Are you 12? I’m being serious.

In dog years.

Originally Posted by BroncoWave

Stats in real games against other teams are very much relevant. Stats in scripted training camp drills against your own defense, most of which hasn't even been in full pads, are not.

Translation; “Stats only matter if my favorite QB is a total ******* scrub”.

Btw, the Jags had the #1 overall pick in the draft, Lock, unfortunately, wasn’t as bad as Garbage Minshew.

Originally Posted by Jaded

Translation; “Stats only matter if my favorite QB is a total ******* scrub”.

Btw, the Jags had the #1 overall pick in the draft, Lock, unfortunately, wasn’t as bad as Garbage Minshew.

Yes, they put no talent around him and were actively trying to lose.

gardener minshew-- because two sub-par QBs just aren't enough!

Originally Posted by Jaded

He’s a scrub, objectively he’s a marginal practice squad talent. I have yet to put enough effort into understanding what you people see in scrubs so don’t ask me to explain it.

If you have a blind spot, which is highly unlikely, you seem to overweight physical attributes and obvious measurables, but underweight that which is, at this primitive point in our objective abilities, relatively less well understood and clinically measured.