Thread: Back Up QB

Originally Posted by Poet

I don't see much in Stidham, but if he does well in New England it's just proof that Belichick made Brady and not vice versa.

I'll always maintain if you swap Brady and Manning throughout their careers, Manning wins at least as many if not more titles than Brady did with BB, and Brady would never win anything.

Originally Posted by BroncoWave

I'll always maintain if you swap Brady and Manning throughout their careers, Manning wins at least as many if not more titles than Brady did with BB, and Brady would never win anything.

Belichick got to a SB when Brady was a nobody and stopped the greatest offense in league history -at that point at least- to nothing. You can't even say 'well they cheated' as a means of defending Brady because he benefited from that elite defense, especially early in his career. Meanwhile Manning had to grow up and carry the load pretty early on.