That's just how I see him. His skills are great. He hurts his team more than he should. Rewatch SB 32. He threw the ball directly to us repeatedly. We dropped numerous INTs he tried to giftwrap to us because he simply won't make the smart play.
That said, its not necessarily just a rings argument. The basis of my view is how an elite talent can leave to much on tbe table due to their inability to adjust and mature. Partly what makes them great, I will concede. But it also a hindrance.
And he had way more talent around him than Marino ever did.