Thread: The All Time Greatest Quarterbacks Thread

Originally Posted by Poet

The GOAT to me is the guy who played the best football over a period of time where he dominated the league, won individual awards, and his team won it all largely BECAUSE of him.

That's not unfair criteria.

It's as good a way of looking at things as anyway else. It's also in line with the logic of getting TD into the HOF for his short but beastly career.

Took a LOOOOONG time and he had more SB wins and a longer period of dominance (so far).

If he continues at his pace you can make this argument. Today, as we sit here, it's a foolish and trollish argument.