Thread: Michael Vick documentary

He is no worse than a fur trapper, fisherman, trophy hunter, cattle rancher, chicken farmer etc

But we like dogs, so he is a monster

Originally Posted by Valar Morghulis

He is no worse than a fur trapper, fisherman, trophy hunter, cattle rancher, chicken farmer etc

But we like dogs, so he is a monster

But OF COURSE you would say something like that. He nailed a ****ing dog to a tree. Its nowhere near the same.

I’ll probably watch eventually. He was one of my favorite players growing up.

If he was white he woulda been banned for life.

Oh wow. Here we go.

Originally Posted by Dapper Dan

Oh wow. Here we go.

No point in even addressing that nonsense. Part one was good, looking forward to part 2.

What he did is indefensible. Period.

I like his attitude.

Originally Posted by Shazam!

What he did is indefensible. Period.

Completely agree. So difficult to defend in real life and Madden. A beast.

Originally Posted by BroncoWave

He doesn't have even close to Vick's arm talent.

If Vick dedicated himself to basketball he would have been Derrick Rose or RWB. If he dedicated himself to baseball he would have been the closest thing to Ricky Henderson. His athletic ability is arguably tops in American history. He's on that Bo Jackson level.

Lamar....is not on that level...but he might end up being a better QB than Vick.

I vaguely remember something about Allen Iverson, Aaron Brooks, and Michael Vick growing up together in Virginia.

Originally Posted by Dapper Dan

I vaguely remember something about Allen Iverson, Aaron Brooks, and Michael Vick growing up together in Virginia.

Allen Iverson was interviewed in part one of the doc. They both grew up in Newport News, VA.

Originally Posted by King87

If Vick dedicated himself to basketball he would have been Derrick Rose or RWB. If he dedicated himself to baseball he would have been the closest thing to Ricky Henderson.

This is a ridiculous take.

But I forgive you.

Originally Posted by slim

This is a ridiculous take.

But I forgive you.

You hate me because I'm white.

Originally Posted by Valar Morghulis

He is no worse than a fur trapper, fisherman, trophy hunter, cattle rancher, chicken farmer etc

But we like dogs, so he is a monster

I disagree. When you fish, you are not pitting the fish against another in a battle to the death. Whereby the battle results in tortuous mutilation that lasts for minutes and the agony can last the rest of the life. If I shoot a deer and it dies, it's a quick death, even if I have to track it for half a mile. If I raise cattle and then use a contraption that kills the cow in fewer than five seconds, that's not comparable, either.

Your logical flaw is rooted in the conclusion that all mistreatment/termination is the same. The cow that dies in three seconds is not equivalent in suffering to a dog that suffers torn flesh, loss of vision, and being beaten to death by the owner because it lost.