Thread: Would Broncos fans rather have Rosen or Allen over Chubb right now?

Originally Posted by Shazam!

Top meaning Top 5 pick people. Wasnt it obvious?

Apparently not.

Originally Posted by Shazam!

Top meaning Top 5 pick people. Wasnt it obvious?

Then why did you say first or second?

This validates my question my brother. Oh...oh my.

For me its not about whether or not you can win a SB without a Franchise/HOF QB, its been done a few times in history. But the reality is especially in the last 30 or so years that for teams that make it regularly to the SB it has involved the team having a franchise/HOF caliber QB on the squad. Its not speculation, its not an opinion, its fact. Even for a guy like Eli who many feel isnt quite a HOF QB he is the Giants franchise QB, he is not a flash in a pan kind of guy like Foles, Dilfer, or Johnson.

Originally Posted by Shazam!

Top meaning Top 5 pick people. Wasnt it obvious?

Not really. Lol

It is what it is. We need a QB. Chubb is a fine player. We roll.

We have The Chad on the roster. Just need to play him. Cannot believe after being up by 30 + points that we did not put him in the game. I thought for sure afer halftime we would. Easily. Then the 4th quarter. Cannot understand that move. not at all.

Originally Posted by underrated29

We have The Chad on the roster. Just need to play him. Cannot believe after being up by 30 + points that we did not put him in the game. I thought for sure afer halftime we would. Easily. Then the 4th quarter. Cannot understand that move. not at all.

Fox didn't put Brock in for Manning until late in the 4th quarter even though we were up nearly 30 points on the Raiders in the last game of 2014. BUT, getting Kelly some game time would have been prudent at some point in the 4th.
You get the torches, I'll get the pitchforks. We'll have VeJayJay's head by morning!

they don't want the fans chanting for kelly the next time numbnuts throws a bad pick. . .

Originally Posted by dogfish

they don't want the fans chanting for kelly the next time numbnuts throws a bad pick. . .

This, plus it's not like they'd really let him do anything. Run the ball only.

We are not making the playoffs. We need to find out what we have in Kelly before the draft. This must be done. I think once we get eliminated we may just go ahead and do that, but god this staff is so incompetent that I am just not sure they will.

Originally Posted by Northman

For me its not about whether or not you can win a SB without a Franchise/HOF QB, its been done a few times in history. But the reality is especially in the last 30 or so years that for teams that make it regularly to the SB it has involved the team having a franchise/HOF caliber QB on the squad. Its not speculation, its not an opinion, its fact. Even for a guy like Eli who many feel isnt quite a HOF QB he is the Giants franchise QB, he is not a flash in a pan kind of guy like Foles, Dilfer, or Johnson.

I have never thought eli was all that. In 2007, for instance I believe he was the 27th rated passer, and while he did get the MVP, it was clearly the Giants defense behind that NASCAR DL that stifled the Pats offense to 14 points that won it.

The list of QBs that won it that sort of rode the coattails is longer than we think. I do put eli in that category. Hostettler, Rypien, even Plunkett who was a bit of a journey guy.

Originally Posted by underrated29

We are not making the playoffs. We need to find out what we have in Kelly before the draft. This must be done. I think once we get eliminated we may just go ahead and do that, but god this staff is so incompetent that I am just not sure they will.

I agree. Unfortunately for us as fans who don't fully understand how much economics effects decisions like that, get frustrated.

Often times, it is more than just a small part of a decision. Keenum makes me sick, and I am confident chad kelly could be better. He could not be worse!!! Anyway, I could be wrong but I do think they are avoiding that, for possible economic ramifications.

I wanted Rosen. I’ll stand by that, own up to saying that for six months.

Originally Posted by MOtorboat

I wanted Rosen. I’ll stand by that, own up to saying that for six months.

did you see his mopey face out there? somebody needs to do a smokin' josh rosen meme. . .

Originally Posted by underrated29

We are not making the playoffs. We need to find out what we have in Kelly before the draft. This must be done. I think once we get eliminated we may just go ahead and do that, but god this staff is so incompetent that I am just not sure they will.

Might be too early to declare that we are not making the playoffs.