Originally Posted by
Von Kinger
Guards are rarely drafted in the top five, though. I understand the argument. However, that wasn't a scream - everyone who watched the games saw that TS in particular didn't step up in the pocket, even when it held up. Saying that the pocket often was a failure doesn't make that mutually exclusive. Talking about TS is a waste of time, though.
To me, a great guard is less impactful than even a good RB, and now it's rare for RB's to be drafted highly - think how good Barkley's grade was to be the second overall. Position matters, scarcity matters. These guards are hitting the free agency market. I'd rather have a stud like Chubb, and have to go and sign a guard then draft a stud guard and have to go sign a pass rusher like Chubb. And because McGovern is still improving but looked promising, taking Nelson over Chubb, even if you dismiss the positional argument, just strikes me as wrong.
I understand your position. You go more for the Madden, fun positions, rather then foundational positions that are needed to win. In Madden, a QB can spin around three times, hurdle two rushers, get outside the pocket and throw a 50 yard shot to a receiver in triple coverage and it be a completion. In the NFL, not so much.
No question that guards are rarely taken in the top five, or even top 10, because rarely do guards this good come out. When they do, they are picked in the top five or top 10, just like Nelson was.
Hopefully, Veldheer's injuries are behind him and he is a solid right tackle. The Broncos have had abysmal right tackle, worst in the league level, for several years. Hopefully, McGovern can play RG at a solid level, and we won't have all the interior pressure that we had last year, and it was a lot.
I'm excited about the Chubb pick, but Nelson was probably the right pick.