I think #2 is unenforceable or at least needs an appeals process.
What if, for example, a demonstrably religious quarterback were to suddenly be the Broncos starting quarterback? Likewise, what if a QB with a history of controversial political stances were to suddenly be the Broncos starting quarterback? What some people will see as needlessly inserting religious or political speech into threads about such a quarterback will be seen by others as harmless or "part of the Broncos' story".
Let's say Aqib Talib leads a BLM protest march and takes a bullet in his other leg? Political or legit Broncos news? Soon, your mods will be splitting hairs and getting called out for being inconsistent.
I miss the old Mile High Stadium.