Thread: If both healthy, which QB starts week 5 and why?

Ok, let's hear it.

I want Lynch to but Siemian probably will.

Tebow. Obv.

Originally Posted by BroncoWave

I want Lynch to but Siemian probably will.

Why?

I'm encouraged by what we saw from Lynch today. I'm glad we got to see what he has in a real game setting.

That being said, I don't replace Siemian. He was good again and I see no reason to mess with success now

Originally Posted by Tned

Why?

Because he is clearly more talented and seemed more than mentally ready to handle regular season football today.

I think Siemian starts next week but i have to say that Lynch easily has a stronger arm and is more athletic and I still think he will eventually be the starter before the end of the season. The play just before we kicked the field goal in the second Lynch did not complete the pass but that stiff arm to avoid the sack was awesome.

Originally Posted by BroncoWave

Because he is clearly more talented and seemed more than mentally ready to handle regular season football today.

Do you think Lynch gives team the best chance to win now, or is it more about willing to sacrifice a little now, to get the long term option ready?

Lynch seems to have the better physical tools, better arm, mobility, bigger, stronger and faster, which is what I said in the other thread. Siemian has a very valuable year already under his belt so I don't question the decision to start him.


Other than the second half in Cincinnati, when Trevor was on fire, I don't see anything that Siemian does that Lynch couldn't do.

I'd start Lynch and get the growing pains out of the way but I understand why Siemian was named the starter. Please try not to misrepresent what I said like you did in the game day thread, Tned. That was a jerk move.

I bet Trevor Siemian, and the main reason is because Kubiak is super gay for Trevor Siemian.

Originally Posted by Jaded

I bet Trevor Siemian, and the main reason is because Kubiak is super gay for Trevor Siemian.

So do you think he just prefers clean shaven men?

Originally Posted by BroncoWave

Because he is clearly more talented and seemed more than mentally ready to handle regular season football today.

Where do you come up with this trash?

Originally Posted by Slick

Lynch seems to have the better physical tools, better arm, mobility, bigger, stronger and faster, which is what I said in the other thread. Siemian has a very valuable year already under his belt so I don't question the decision to start him.


Other than the second half in Cincinnati, when Trevor was on fire, I don't see anything that Siemian does that Lynch couldn't do.

I'd start Lynch and get the growing pains out of the way but I understand why Siemian was named the starter. Please try not to misrepresent what I said like you did in the game day thread, Tned. That was a jerk move.

You said that you believed the team would have the same record with Lynch, among other things.

I would be fine with either one starting. Siemian was bad for 2 games and really good last week. He was pretty good in limited opportunities today and then started to get eaten up by the D-line.

Lynch looked raw as you'd expect, but he showed off that canon arm and his athleticism, made plays, and looked like he was more than comfortable running the offense. He can play from under center just fine (lol at Wilcotts) and looked to have a good feel for the game.

Lynch is a better QB, but if you go to Lynch now, you really can't go back. If you put Trevor back in there you can always replace him with Lynch later if he struggles. Like I said I'm fine with either one, but I think I'd just go all in with Lynch.

Originally Posted by Canmore

Where do you come up with this trash?

So you think Lynch isn't talented? Or did he do something to show you he isn't ready to play in the NFL right now? If so, what makes you think that?