Sure, and I was wrong: We could easily have had BOTH, and a couple championships by now. Since we decided Manning was a one-man offense, it doesn't MATTER.
It's not that I didn't want him, it's that I thought he'd be WASTED on us because we couldn't give him anything but Clady, DT and Decker, and expecting an old, immobile bionic QB fresh off FOUR SPINAL SURGERIES to last a whole season, much less win a SB, was a fools errand. Was that belief false?