I grew up reading a lot of Steven King, Dean Koontz, Michael Crichton, and so on. Always been a fan of the supernatural and all that.
Thnik just shared Welcome to Night Vale with me, thanks man. I need more of that stuff. Sooo creepy and surreal. I wish there was no Carlos, but hey that's me.
Even more recently, I've found Pseudopod. It's a catalog of some 300+ supernatural/horror shorts, narrated by different folks. Some of them are very, very good.
It's hard to pick a favorite or anything, but I listened to one yesterday about a dude that takes home some random homemade video game that is pretty warped. Pretty dark and disturbing.
For you addictive personalities out there, you might enjoy this one about a professor with a tobacco pipe habit that goes a bit too far...
Make some noise if this is your kind of thing.