Thread: Vastly, VASTLY overrated.

Originally Posted by atwater27

Lay off of Peyton. Besides, his lesser skilled brother owns the Patriots. Owns their little asses.

Get real.

Ellie Mae 'triumphed' against two of the worst pass defenses ever to play in the SB. Paste and glue, smoke and mirrors. And he still looked pedestrian. Also was the beneficiary of perhaps the most fortuitous single play in SB history, eclipsing even "The Immaculate Reception", in 2007.

The Giants defense won those games, playing on a different plateau, so give them credit. But don't try to sell the ides that Manning was the hero.

Originally Posted by bronconut

Eli, Peyton, and Tom are all very good to great quarterbacks. one's not necessarily better than the other and any given day. they are different from each other, but each is special in his or her own way.

I would have to agree with you, Nut, if you only mentioned Tom and Peyton. Eli will have to do a lot more than be on a couple of SB teams in order to get into that conversation, don't you think?

It doesn't matter. Eli is and will always be a Patriot Killer. took away 2 rings from the brady bunch. Gotta love it.

Originally Posted by Mr Bojangles

I would have to agree with you, Nut, if you only mentioned Tom and Peyton. Eli will have to do a lot more than be on a couple of SB teams in order to get into that conversation, don't you think?

not really Bo, i think Eli is better than both those chumps combined

Originally Posted by atwater27

I wouldn't include Eli in Tom or Peytons class. He will never be in the conversation for greatest QB ever.

I dont' think I really care for your attitude

Originally Posted by bronconut

I dont' think I really care for your attitude

I concur.