Thread: Buff's Elitist Movie Review Thread

This is a thread where we attempt to identify movies that don't suck.

As such, Mastershake, Northman and MO are not allowed to post in here. Nor is anyone who has ever enjoyed a movie based on a comic book.

So please, no reviews of sequels. No musicals. No animated movies. No chick flicks. No sci-fi. No fantasy. This is for the cream of the crop only. There are other threads where you can go slumming for the latest Avengers 27 review, or to hear about Star Wars episode 13b.

So... Who'd like to get things kicked off?

Originally Posted by Buff

Here is a list of confirmed great movies:

Pulp Fiction
Gangs of New York
American Beauty
The Departed
The Godfather
Goodfellas
Casino
Full Metal Jacket
Requiem for a Dream
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
Rounders
The Big Lebowski
Wayne's World
There Will Be Blood
Forrest Gump
City of God
Gladiator
Braveheart
The Prestige
Mystic River
Dead Man Walking