I just started playing this little gem on the PC, the only platform I use for gaming. I have previously played LOTRO, and WOW prior to that. Decided I wanted a different genre, and on an impulse bought TSW. I did read some reviews, but it was a leap of faith to buy without trying it or being in the beta.
In short, I absolutely LOVE THIS GAME! Combat is a little more interesting than LOTRO or WOW, in that you have to take action in order to dodge, rather than it being automatic like many games. The quests and storyline are logical and thought provoking. There are quite a bit of puzzles to solve, and a variety of quest types. You still have the "go kill x number of bad guys" types quests, though not to the point of monotony like LOTRO and WOW became (IMO).
I don't participate in PvP in most games, though I will no doubt do so in TSW sooner or later, just not a priority for me, so I can't comment on that.
In all, this is one of the funnest games I've played in a long while (not just because I recently started either). Is anyone else playing it?