I totally agree. I thought it was really awesome when I saw it in the theater, but it is so very flawed. Nolan as a director of the Batman stuff tries really hard to be incredibly deep and stuff in order to contrast from the Marvel movies which are generally not that way at all. But he's not really good at doing that with any of the Batman's. I still enjoy them but everybody thinks they're the best things ever because they're summer blockbuster movies framed in a way where they seem like more than that. All of the deep and amazing stuff in them is actually really basic, but it's kindof unexpected so everybody trips out over it. In a way, it's like pseudo-intellectual filmmaking. He is fantastic at making you leave the theater feeling like you've seen the most badass life-changing movie ever. After giving them time to sit, they kindof lose that theater excitement, and you can never pinpoint what exactly it is that made it so badas and life-changing. TDKR was one of the best theater experiences I can remember having. I love watching them, but i'm not going to act like they're perfect or anything.
As for the newest one, I liked most things like Bane and JGL and all. Hathaway in the Catsuit is hubba-hubba. Bane has never stood out as a Batman-like character. He's not bad or anything, but he's definitely replaceable IMO. It was a good watch, exciting, etc. Crowd pleasing. Not as intellectually significant as it thinks it is, but it was good.