PDA

View Full Version : Krieger: Defense's woes front and center



omac
03-29-2009, 02:50 AM
http://www.denverpost.com/krieger/ci_12020710

Krieger: Defense's woes front and center
By Dave Krieger
The Denver Post
Posted: 03/29/2009 12:30:00 AM MDT
Updated: 03/29/2009 01:38:54 AM MDT


On the bright side, no one's asking about the defense anymore.

Not saying Josh McDaniels triggered the Jay Cutler fiasco on purpose — that would be like blowing up your house to avoid cleaning the bathroom — but it's been a pretty effective distraction from his football team's biggest problem.

Twenty-seven days from the NFL draft, the Broncos' new coach has already turned over about a quarter of the roster, but he's done very little to improve one of the worst front sevens in football.

Whatever the young coach thinks of his incumbent Pro Bowl quarterback, his team's biggest problem, by far, is the defense, which was bad last year in pretty much every way imaginable.

Shortly after the free-agent market opened a month ago, McDaniels aggressively rebuilt the secondary. He replaced cornerback Dre Bly and safeties Marquand Manuel and Marlon McCree with free agents Andre Goodman, Renaldo Hill and Brian Dawkins, leaving only Champ Bailey as a holdover from last year. This looks like a net improvement, the biggest question being how much Dawkins has left at 35.

By comparison, the front seven has gotten almost no attention. Mc-Daniels signed a few backups, including linebacker Andra Davis, lineman Darrell Reid and a couple of nose tackle suspects, but he has not signed a single new starter.

Given that a stout defense starts up front, there was reason to think this would be McDaniels' first priority in free agency. It was widely assumed that monster defensive tackle Albert Haynesworth would be too expensive for the Broncos, but defensive ends Chris Canty and Igor Olshansky looked like good fits for Mike Nolan's 3-4 defense.

Seven hours into free agency, Redskins owner Daniel Snyder signed Haynesworth to a deal that could be worth $100 million. Three days later, the Giants signed Canty to a six-year, $42 million deal, a reported $17.5 million of it guaranteed. Four days after that, the Cowboys replaced Canty with Olshansky, who got a four-year deal worth $18 million, $8 million of it guaranteed.

Even these latter deals might seem too rich for the Broncos' blood, given their multiplicity of needs and Pat Bowlen's recent aversion to large signing bonuses. But Bowlen did approve a five-year deal worth $17 million for Dawkins, a reported $7.2 million of it guaranteed.

That's pretty close to the deal Olshansky got from Dallas. Choosing a 35-year-old safety over a 26-year-old defensive end might make sense as the final piece of the puzzle, but it's a little harder to figure as part of a reconstruction project.

Barring a major draft-day deal, McDaniels now seems compelled to use the draft to restock the front seven, which casts some doubt on his pitch to the veteran defensive backs he is looking to win right away.

According to the conventional wisdom, if Boston College defensive tackle B.J. Raji is available at No. 12, the Broncos will take him to play the nose in their evolving 3-4. If he's gone by No. 12, the most popular alternative in early mock drafts is defensive end Tyson Jackson of LSU.

Adding intrigue, the Lions, who own the first pick and have expressed interest in Cutler, had Raji in for a workout, raising all sorts of trade possibilities.

Another massive defensive tackle — Ron Brace of Boston College or Evander Hood of Missouri — might be available at No. 48, the Broncos' second pick. After that, if the Broncos get anyone ready to start in the NFL right away, they will be very lucky.

The problem with going for linemen at the top of the draft is the Broncos also need major upgrades at linebacker, where D.J. Williams is the only holdover from last year's starting group. The highest-rated inside backers in the draft — Rey Maualuga of USC and James Laurinaitis of Ohio State — are generally projected to be taken in between the Broncos' first two picks.

In short, a month into free agency, McDaniels' reconstruction of the NFL's 30th-ranked scoring defense is only one-third done. Cutler may be his biggest public relations problem, but he's nowhere near his biggest football problem.

Dave Krieger: 303-954-5297 or dkrieger@denverpost.com

Dean
03-29-2009, 07:08 AM
McKid may have gone ultra light on the guts and flanks of the 2009 Broncos defense but he did pick up a legion of running backs, a number 4 receiver, and a snapper. Way to fix what ain't broke. Better be one H of a draft or we run the risk of even being worse than last year- possibly significantly worse.

:questionmark:

Fan in Exile
03-29-2009, 07:22 AM
I think Krieger is wrong about what should have been done in free agency.

I completely agree with not signing Canty or Olshansky. We've got the most players on our roster who can play a 3-4 DE and it's the easiest transition to make. Haynesworth as well would be a total waste here, we need a NT not a DT.

It's not like there was a really good NT prospect out there in FA. We could have given up a pick for Watson, but at this point in rebuilding I don't think it's a good idea. So getting a couple of prospects and drafting one seems like the best plan to me.

Andra Davis would probably be surprised to find out that he's not going to be starting. I mean being beaten out in camp is a possibility but who's going to be the starter in his place right now?

Linebacker is also one of the easiest to step into as a rookie it's why so often the DROY candidates are LBs.

If we get a Linebacker and Brace in rounds one and two all of a sudden our front seven looks a lot better.

I also don't know where he's getting this conventional wisdom has us picking Tyson Jackson Scout.com's mock draft muncher has Mauluga as the most popular pick by far.

He also forgot the biggest difference between this year and last which is of course firing Bob Slowick.

WARHORSE
03-29-2009, 07:59 AM
Draft day will tell us all we need to know about what McD thinks of the front seven.

Im thinking there are some players lifting alot of weight right now.

Hope we pick the right guys on draft day.

omac
03-29-2009, 10:21 AM
I thought this was a pretty good point ....

"Barring a major draft-day deal, McDaniels now seems compelled to use the draft to restock the front seven, which casts some doubt on his pitch to the veteran defensive backs he is looking to win right away."

Our DL now isn't exactly stocked with players who would start for other teams, and there's usually a significant learning curve for drafted DL players to adjust to the NFL, so that statement seems to be correct.

However, Shanahan has used a similar approach by getting Lynch and Champ, while getting non-highly sought after players for the DL in the Browncos. With Coyer coaching the defense, and with Al in the middle, plus Champ and Lynch, we were able to mask some of the weaknesses we had in talent in our DL.

Maybe McDaniels is hoping the fix in the back-end will be able to mask current weaknesses in the front-end, while the drafted line players learn their craft. In order for this to work, though, I think we need to pick up a great ILB.

tubby
03-29-2009, 10:36 AM
Andra Davis and Ronnie Fields will start.

Fan in Exile
03-29-2009, 11:25 AM
The other thing that the article didn't take into consideration is that they are planning on using a hybrid defense next year not a pure 3-4. That takes a pressure of off the rookies and the rest of the team and will allow them to develop at their own pace.

As long as it's done correctly.

silkamilkamonico
03-29-2009, 01:29 PM
McKid may have gone ultra light on the guts and flanks of the 2009 Broncos defense ...

Great point. We all know how "stable" and "cornerstone" it was last year under Shanahan.

;)

Shazam!
03-29-2009, 01:37 PM
This isn't rocket science. Denver will use almost all their picks for defense. As for NT, Nolan knows Fields, that's why he was brought in and he will be a starter. The new scheme alone will improve the defense. Even if they become a middle-of-the-pack group, as sad as that sounds that would be a major improvement.

Lonestar
03-29-2009, 02:47 PM
This isn't rocket science. Denver will use almost all their picks for defense. As for NT, Nolan knows Fields, that's why he was brought in and he will be a starter. The new scheme alone will improve the defense. Even if they become a middle-of-the-pack group, as sad as that sounds that would be a major improvement.

even if they remain the same with a bunch of rookies learning their jobs it is a win win.. Building via the draft is what is needed.. with a sprinkling of Solid leader vets to teach the rookies self esteem and swagger..

having a real DC and some real position coaches not just yes men will be a refreshing change, from the stench of 2007-08.

Cugel
03-29-2009, 04:36 PM
I thought this was a pretty good point ....

However, Shanahan has used a similar approach by getting Lynch and Champ, while getting non-highly sought after players for the DL in the Browncos. With Coyer coaching the defense, and with Al in the middle, plus Champ and Lynch, we were able to mask some of the weaknesses we had in talent in our DL.

Maybe McDaniels is hoping the fix in the back-end will be able to mask current weaknesses in the front-end, while the drafted line players learn their craft. In order for this to work, though, I think we need to pick up a great ILB.

The Browncos were all former #1 draft picks who had been cut loose by their teams for underachieving/injury. Shanahan gambled that he could make do for a season or two with these guys, and he was right!

In 2005 Courtney Brown had his last season and was strong at DE, especially against the run. Gerard Warren had his "salary drive" and won a big contract, after which he was never seen again and is now backing up a horrible Oakland DL.

Ebeneezer Ekuban and John Engleberger were at least adequate. With these guys and a blitzing defense and a better than expected offense with Jake Plummer's last gasp, the Broncos actually got to the AFC title game.

But, Shanahan made the major mistake that ultimately cost him his career. Instead of focusing on finding some DL to come in and learn behind Warren/Brown/Ekuban/Engleberger, he traded away his #1 pick to the Redskins, and then picked 3 CBs on day 1, of whom only Darrent Williams panned out for Denver -- alas for a short time.

Faced with an aging team and a severe shortage of talent Shanahan tried to stock up the offense with Cutler, Sheffler, Marshall, Clady, and Harris, while trying to get by with cast-offs on defense.

This season he would probably have focused on strengthening the defense and hoped that with luck by next year he'd have a serious threat to win the SB. He just ran out of time and Pat Bowlen's patience.

But, McDaniels has NOT brought in any equivalent of the Browncos. Ron Fields is a career backup -- a scrub who might drift around the league without ever making an impact.

That's pretty much it for DL help so far.

There are nothing but question marks on this defense which is why it's so amazingly stupid that McDaniels tried to get rid of the ONE thing that actually was any good on the Broncos -- Jay Cutler. :coffee:

omac
03-30-2009, 04:00 AM
The Browncos were all former #1 draft picks who had been cut loose by their teams for underachieving/injury. Shanahan gambled that he could make do for a season or two with these guys, and he was right!

In 2005 Courtney Brown had his last season and was strong at DE, especially against the run. Gerard Warren had his "salary drive" and won a big contract, after which he was never seen again and is now backing up a horrible Oakland DL.

Ebeneezer Ekuban and John Engleberger were at least adequate. With these guys and a blitzing defense and a better than expected offense with Jake Plummer's last gasp, the Broncos actually got to the AFC title game.

But, Shanahan made the major mistake that ultimately cost him his career. Instead of focusing on finding some DL to come in and learn behind Warren/Brown/Ekuban/Engleberger, he traded away his #1 pick to the Redskins, and then picked 3 CBs on day 1, of whom only Darrent Williams panned out for Denver -- alas for a short time.

Faced with an aging team and a severe shortage of talent Shanahan tried to stock up the offense with Cutler, Sheffler, Marshall, Clady, and Harris, while trying to get by with cast-offs on defense.

This season he would probably have focused on strengthening the defense and hoped that with luck by next year he'd have a serious threat to win the SB. He just ran out of time and Pat Bowlen's patience.

But, McDaniels has NOT brought in any equivalent of the Browncos. Ron Fields is a career backup -- a scrub who might drift around the league without ever making an impact.

That's pretty much it for DL help so far.

There are nothing but question marks on this defense which is why it's so amazingly stupid that McDaniels tried to get rid of the ONE thing that actually was any good on the Broncos -- Jay Cutler. :coffee:

Great post! :salute: